In partnership with
Hey, Grow Newsie reader!
As we head into 2026, the newsletter landscape is more competitive than ever. With 45% of creators expecting profits to surge over the next 12 months, now's the time to experiment with fresh growth tactics.
I've researched what's actually working for top newsletter operators right now, and I'm sharing 10 concrete experiments you can run to grow your subscriber base. These aren't theoretical—they're battle-tested tactics from newsletters that have seen real results.
Let's dive in.
Sponsored by: LINDY AI
AI that works like a teammate, not a chatbot
Most “AI tools” talk... a lot. Lindy actually does the work.
It builds AI agents that handle sales, marketing, support, and more.
Describe what you need, and Lindy builds it:
“Qualify sales leads”
“Summarize customer calls”
“Draft weekly reports”
The result: agents that do the busywork while your team focuses on growth.
Experiment 1: Launch a 30-Day Pop-Up Newsletter
What it is: Create a limited-time daily newsletter separate from your main publication.
Why it works: Pop-up newsletters create urgency and give you a concentrated way to test cross-promotions. One creator used this approach to gain 3,714 subscribers in just 30 days, with 1,757 being completely new to their audience.
How to test it:
Choose a focused topic related to your niche
Commit to daily emails for 30 days
Feature other newsletter creators (built-in cross-promotion)
Create a unique signup page separate from your main list
Include a compelling reason to reply to each email
Key metric: New subscribers + reply rate
Experiment 2: Optimize for "Internal Shares"
What it is: Create content specifically designed to be shared in company Slack channels and internal forums.
Why it works: When someone at a major company shares your content internally, you can suddenly get dozens of high-quality subscribers from a single organization. This is particularly powerful for B2B newsletters.
How to test it:
Write comprehensive guides that solve specific workplace problems
Make content easily scannable with clear takeaways
Include frameworks or templates people can immediately use
Track subscriber sources to identify which companies are sharing your work
Double down on topics that generate internal shares
Key metric: Subscribers from corporate domains
Experiment 3: Use Loom Videos as Lead Magnets
What it is: Create free Loom tutorial videos and include a subtle subscribe button in the corner.
Why it works: People share these videos because the content is completely free with no email gate, but viewers can easily subscribe if they want more.
How to test it:
Identify your most valuable expertise or process
Create 3-5 minute Loom videos showing exactly how to do something
Add a "Subscribe" button overlay in the video corner
Share on Twitter/LinkedIn threads with step-by-step tips
Track click-through rates on the subscribe button
Key metric: Video shares + subscribe conversion rate
Experiment 4: Build a Referral Program with Strategic Rewards
What it is: Implement a tiered referral system with rewards that align with your audience's interests.
Why it works: Referral programs leverage your existing subscribers to bring in qualified leads. The right rewards can turn casual readers into active promoters.
How to test it:
Set up rewards at 3, 5, 10, and 25 referrals
Make early rewards achievable (3 referrals unlocks something valuable)
Offer exclusive content, templates, or access rather than generic prizes
Promote your referral program in every email footer
Feature top referrers in your newsletter
Key metric: Referral rate (% of subscribers who refer at least one person)
Experiment 5: Leverage Upscribe Cross-Promotion
What it is: Use post-subscription widgets that recommend other newsletters with one-click subscribes.
Why it works: This captures attention when engagement is highest (right after someone subscribes). One newsletter operator credits cross-promotion tools as a massive part of recent growth, even subsidizing paid acquisition costs.
How to test it:
Partner with 3-5 complementary newsletters for reciprocal promotion
Place the widget on your thank-you page
Track which partners drive the most subscribers back to you
Rotate partners monthly to test different audiences
Consider paid placements for faster growth
Key metric: Post-subscription conversion rate
Experiment 6: Reply to Every Mention (The "Reply Guy" Strategy)
What it is: Consistently respond to tweets and posts related to your niche, mentioning you'll feature them in your newsletter.
Why it works: One creator's single reply to a CEO's tweet generated 26,000 views and hundreds of subscribers. Consistency builds visibility and positions you as the go-to resource.
How to test it:
Set up alerts for keywords in your niche
Spend 30 minutes daily engaging with relevant tweets
Offer genuine value, not just self-promotion
Actually feature the best contributions in your newsletter
Track which types of replies drive the most subscriptions
Key metric: Subscribers per reply + engagement rate
Experiment 7: Create Multi-Platform Teasers
What it is: Meet audiences where they already spend time by using social for discovery and email for deep engagement.
Why it works: Some creators have built 69,000+ subscriber newsletters primarily through TikTok and Instagram, proving you don't need to stick to traditional written platforms.
How to test it:
Choose one video platform (TikTok, Instagram Reels, or YouTube Shorts)
Create 30-60 second teasers of your newsletter content
Include a clear CTA to "Get the full breakdown via email"
Use platform-specific formats (don't just repurpose)
Post 3-4 times per week consistently
Key metric: Video views to subscriber conversion rate
Experiment 8: Launch a Weekly Roundup Format
What it is: Curate the best tools, resources, and updates in your niche into a scannable weekly digest.
Why it works: People appreciate newsletters that save them time. Positioning yourself as a filter for what matters most builds loyalty and shareability.
How to test it:
Identify 5-7 categories your audience cares about
Keep items brief (2-3 sentences each)
Include your unique take or why it matters
Make it skimmable with clear sections
Track which items get the most clicks
Key metric: Click-through rate by section
Experiment 9: Leverage AI for Personalized Content
What it is: Use AI tools to customize newsletter content based on subscriber behavior and preferences.
Why it works: 28% of successful creators now use AI for brainstorming and content creation, reclaiming 1-3 hours weekly. This time can be redirected to growth activities.
How to test it:
Segment subscribers by engagement level and interests
Use AI to generate topic ideas based on trending searches
A/B test AI-assisted subject lines vs. manual ones
Create personalized recommendations for different segments
Track which AI-generated elements perform best
Key metric: Open rate lift from personalization
Experiment 10: Focus on Local or Niche Communities
What it is: Narrow your focus to a specific geographic area or underserved niche within your broader topic.
Why it works: Local newsletters are significantly monetizing through various methods, with some growing to 16,000 subscribers and generating $100,000 in revenue in just one year.
How to test it:
Identify an underserved geographic or interest-based community
Tailor content specifically to their unique challenges
Partner with local businesses or niche brands for sponsorships
Engage with community groups and forums
Track engagement rates vs. your broader list
Key metric: Engagement rate + monetization per subscriber
How to Run These Experiments
Don't try all 10 at once. Here's my recommended approach:
Month 1: Pick 2 experiments that align with your current strengths
Month 2: Analyze results and double down on what's working
Month 3: Add 1-2 new experiments while maintaining winners
Remember: Word-of-mouth remains the most effective growth strategy, with 42% of successful creators citing direct recommendations. Any experiment that gets people talking about your newsletter is worth pursuing.
The Bottom Line
Newsletter growth in 2026 requires experimentation. The tactics that worked in 2023 might not deliver the same results today, and what works for one newsletter might flop for another.
The key is to test methodically, measure religiously, and scale what works for your specific audience. Start with one experiment this week.
What are you going to test first? Hit reply and let me know—I read every response.
Keep growing!
With love,
Nikhil
How was today's edition?
If you’ve ever thought about starting your own newsletter (or switching to a better platform), I’ve partnered with the beehiiv team to set you up with:
✅ 20% off your first 3 months
✅ A free 30-day trial, no credit card needed
