In partnership with
Hey, Grow Newsie reader!
Happy Halloween 👻
Today, we're diving into the dark corners of newsletter growth—the mistakes that haunt even the most ambitious creators. These aren't just minor hiccups; they're growth killers that can keep your subscriber count flat-lining for months (or years).
The scariest part? Most creators don't even realize they're making these mistakes until it's too late.
Let's shine a light on these newsletter ghouls and banish them from your strategy forever.
Sponsored by: 1440 Media
Join over 4 million Americans who start their day with 1440 – your daily digest for unbiased, fact-centric news. From politics to sports, we cover it all by analyzing over 100 sources. Our concise, 5-minute read lands in your inbox each morning at no cost. Experience news without the noise; let 1440 help you make up your own mind. Sign up now and invite your friends and family to be part of the informed.
The Horror: You've created amazing content, but your newsletter signup is buried three clicks deep on your website. It's like throwing a Halloween party and forgetting to send out invitations.
The Statistics: According to industry data, newsletters with multiple visible signup options can see 50-70% more conversions than those with single, hidden forms.
How to Fix It:
Put your newsletter signup in your social media bio (ditch Linktree if growing your newsletter is priority #1)
Add it to your website navigation menu
Create a sticky sidebar or footer signup form
Add inline CTAs in your blog posts
Use exit-intent popups (but do it right—more on that below)
Pro Tip: Make your newsletter signup the ONLY link in your bio if growth is your main priority. You can share other resources with subscribers once they're on your list.
🧟 Mistake #2: The Zombie Content (Sending the Same Message to Everyone)
The Horror: Treating all 5,000 subscribers the same when they have wildly different interests and engagement levels. It's like serving garlic bread at a vampire convention.
The Reality Check: Personalized emails deliver 6x higher transaction rates, yet 70% of brands fail to use them effectively.
How to Fix It:
Segment your list by interest, engagement level, or signup source
Use the subscriber's name (but do it naturally—not every sentence)
Create different content tracks for different audience segments
Send behavior-based emails (e.g., re-engagement campaigns for inactive subscribers)
Test different content for different segments
Quick Win: Start simple. Create just two segments: "Highly Engaged" and "Needs Re-engagement." Tailor your content accordingly.
🕷️ Mistake #3: The Ghost Town Welcome (No Welcome Email)
The Horror: A new subscriber joins your list and... crickets. No welcome email, no introduction, no clear expectations. They're left wondering if they even subscribed correctly.
Why This Kills Growth: Your welcome email is your MOST-READ email (typically 50-86% open rates). Missing this opportunity is like turning away trick-or-treaters on Halloween night.
How to Fix It:
Set up an automated welcome email immediately
Introduce yourself and your newsletter
Set clear expectations (when they'll hear from you, what they'll get)
Deliver immediate value (a lead magnet, your best content, or exclusive insight)
Ask for a reply to warm up their inbox
Link to your best past editions
Template:
Subject: Welcome to [Newsletter Name]! Here's what happens next...
Hey [Name]!
Thanks for joining [X] subscribers who get [specific benefit] every [day/week].
Here's what to expect:
- You'll hear from me every [frequency]
- Each edition contains [specific value]
- Hit reply anytime—I read every response
To get started, here's [valuable resource/insight].
See you in your inbox!
[Your Name]🦇 Mistake #4: The Frankenstein's Monster (Inconsistent Content and Format)
The Horror: Your newsletter changes every week. One week it's a 5-minute read with curated links. Next week it's a 2,000-word essay. Then it's a video. Your subscribers have no idea what to expect.
Why It Kills Growth: Inconsistency destroys trust and makes it impossible for readers to share your newsletter. How can they recommend it if they can't explain what it is?
How to Fix It:
Choose ONE format and stick with it (at least for 3-6 months)
Establish a consistent structure (same sections each week)
Maintain consistent length (±20% is fine, but don't go from 200 to 2,000 words)
Keep the same tone and voice
Send on the same day/time each week
The Six Proven Newsletter Formats:
Opinion-based editorial
Curated resource roundup
Review-based analysis
Case study/deep dive
News-based reporting
Educational how-to
Choose one. Master it. Then experiment if needed.
🧛 Mistake #5: The Blood Sucker (Too Promotional, Zero Value)
The Horror: Every email is a sales pitch. Buy this, sign up for that, check out my new course. Your subscribers feel like they're being drained, not served.
The 90/10 Rule: Spend 90% of your content providing genuine value (education, entertainment, inspiration) and only 10% promoting your products or services.
How to Fix It:
Ask yourself before hitting send: "What value does this provide?"
Focus on teaching, sharing insights, or solving problems
When you do promote, explain the benefit, not just the feature
Build trust first, sell second
Use storytelling instead of hard selling
Remember: Newsletters are a long-term brand-building game, not a direct sales channel.
👻 Mistake #6: The Phantom Analytics (Not Tracking What Matters)
The Horror: You're sending newsletters into the void with no idea what's working. Are people opening? Clicking? Engaging? You have no clue.
Why This Kills Growth: You can't improve what you don't measure.
Key Metrics to Track:
Open Rate: 30-40% is healthy (but don't obsess—it's partially broken due to Apple Mail Privacy)
Click-Through Rate (CTR): 2-5% is good, 10%+ is excellent
Unsubscribe Rate: Under 0.5% is healthy
Reply Rate: The hidden gem—aim for 1-3%
Growth Rate: Week-over-week and month-over-month new subscribers
Conversion Rate: If monetization is your goal
How to Fix It:
Review metrics after EVERY send
A/B test subject lines, send times, and content
Pay attention to which topics drive the most engagement
Survey your audience quarterly
Track trends over time, not just individual campaign performance
Pro Tip: Your most engaged subscribers are your secret weapon. Track who replies, who clicks consistently, and treat them like VIPs.
🎃 Mistake #7: The Cursed Mindset (No Monetization Strategy)
The Horror: You're a year into your newsletter with 5,000 subscribers and zero monetization strategy. You suddenly realize your niche can't support the business model you want.
Why This Kills Growth (and Your Business): Newsletter burnout is real. Without a path to monetization, you'll eventually quit—no matter how passionate you are.
How to Fix It:
Think about monetization from Day 1 (even if you don't implement immediately)
Choose a niche with proven monetization potential
Understand your audience's pain points and spending ability
Test multiple revenue streams
The Four Main Monetization Models:
Paid Subscriptions - Charge for premium content ($5-50/month)
Sponsorships & Ads - Sell space to relevant brands ($25-100+ CPM)
Affiliate Marketing - Earn commissions on product recommendations (5-30% per sale)
Your Own Products/Services - Sell courses, templates, coaching, or digital products
Start Simple: Pick ONE model that aligns with your content and audience. Master it before adding others.
🕸️ BONUS: The Quick Fix Checklist
Print this out and tape it to your desk:
Before Every Send:
✅ Does this provide genuine value to my readers?
✅ Is my CTA clear and compelling?
✅ Have I proofread for typos and broken links?
✅ Is it mobile-friendly?
✅ Does it match my usual format and voice?
✅ Have I tested the subject line?
Monthly Review:
✅ What were my top 3 performing emails? Why?
✅ What was my growth rate?
✅ Did my open/click rates trend up or down?
✅ How many replies did I get?
✅ What feedback did I receive?
🌙 The Final Exorcism: Your Action Plan
Pick ONE mistake from today's edition that resonates most with you. That's the demon you're going to exorcise this week.
Don't try to fix everything at once. That's how you get overwhelmed and quit.
This Week's Challenge: Choose your biggest mistake and implement ONE fix before your next send.
📚 Resources Worth Your Time
Segmentation Made Simple: Most email platforms (ConvertKit, Beehiiv, Substack) have built-in segmentation tools. Start with 2-3 basic segments.
A/B Testing Guide: Test one element at a time (subject line, send time, or CTA) for reliable data.
Welcome Email Templates: Check out successful newsletters in your niche and model their welcome sequences.
Remember: Every successful newsletter creator has made these mistakes. The difference? They fixed them.
You're not behind. You're just getting started on the right path.
Here's to vanquishing those newsletter demons! 🎃
Keep growing!
With love,
Nikhil
How was today's edition?
If you’ve ever thought about starting your own newsletter (or switching to a better platform), I’ve partnered with the beehiiv team to set you up with:
✅ 20% off your first 3 months
✅ A free 30-day trial, no credit card needed
