In partnership with
Two newsletters can publish every week.
Both can be well written.
Both can be consistent.
Yet one grows steadily…
while the other quietly stalls.
The difference is who the newsletter is built for.
Let’s talk about Audience-First vs Creator-First newsletters.
Sponsored by: GLADLY AI
Your competitors are already automating. Here's the data.
Retail and ecommerce teams using AI for customer service are resolving 40-60% more tickets without more staff, cutting cost-per-ticket by 30%+, and handling seasonal spikes 3x faster.
But here's what separates winners from everyone else: they started with the data, not the hype.
Gladly handles the predictable volume, FAQs, routing, returns, order status, while your team focuses on customers who need a human touch. The result? Better experiences. Lower costs. Real competitive advantage. Ready to see what's possible for your business?
Creator-first newsletters usually focus on:
What the creator wants to write
What feels interesting that week
Personal updates without a clear takeaway
They sound like:
“Here’s what I’ve been thinking about lately…”
These newsletters aren’t bad.
They’re just harder to grow and monetize.
Why?
Because readers don’t wake up thinking about you.
They think about their problems.
Audience-first newsletters start with:
Reader pain
Reader curiosity
Reader outcomes
They sound like:
“Here’s something that will help you today…”
Every edition answers one silent question:
Why should I spend time on this right now?
Clarity compounds.
They struggle because:
Value is inconsistent
Sharing feels awkward
Monetization feels forced
Readers may like the creator…
But they don’t need the newsletter.
And growth follows need—not personality.
Audience-first newsletters:
Get forwarded more
Build trust quicker
Monetize more naturally
When readers feel understood, they:
Open more
Reply more
Pay more willingly
Trust isn’t built by self-expression.
It’s built by relevance.
🧠 The balance most creators miss
This isn’t about removing personality.
The best newsletters are:
Audience-first in value
Creator-first in voice
Your experience matters.
Your opinions matter.
But they should serve the reader’s outcome—not replace it.
🏁 Final Thought
If your newsletter growth feels slow, ask yourself:
“Is this written for expression—or for impact?”
Creators who win long-term learn this shift early:
Audience first. Always.
How was today's edition?
If you’ve ever thought about starting your own newsletter (or switching to a better platform), I’ve partnered with the beehiiv team to set you up with:
✅ 20% off your first 3 months
✅ A free 30-day trial, no credit card needed
