In partnership with
Let’s challenge a belief most creators never question:
Bigger audience = better newsletter.
It sounds logical.
It looks impressive.
It feels validating.
But it’s often wrong.
Let’s talk about why audience quality beats audience size—especially for newsletters.
Sponsored by: FISHER INVESTMENTS
What Will Your Retirement Look Like?
Planning for retirement raises many questions. Have you considered how much it will cost, and how you’ll generate the income you’ll need to pay for it? For many, these questions can feel overwhelming, but answering them is a crucial step forward for a comfortable future.
Start by understanding your goals, estimating your expenses and identifying potential income streams. The Definitive Guide to Retirement Income can help you navigate these essential questions. If you have $1,000,000 or more saved for retirement, download your free guide today to learn how to build a clear and effective retirement income plan. Discover ways to align your portfolio with your long-term goals, so you can reach the future you deserve.
📉 The vanity metric trap
Subscriber count is visible.
Engagement is invisible.
A newsletter with:
20,000 subscribers
18% open rate
Minimal replies
Can earn less than one with:
2,000 subscribers
55% open rate
Consistent engagement
Size inflates ego.
Quality builds businesses.
🧠 What “audience quality” actually means
High-quality subscribers:
Open regularly
Care about the topic
Trust your voice
Act on recommendations
They don’t just exist in your list.
They participate in it.
And participation is what drives:
Referrals
Sales
Retention
Revenue
💸 Why quality monetizes better
Sponsors care about:
Attention
Alignment
Conversion
Subscribers care about:
Relevance
Outcomes
Trust
Neither cares about inflated numbers.
A small, aligned audience can:
Convert better
Stay longer
Spend more
That’s leverage.
📈 Why chasing size backfires
When growth becomes the only goal, creators:
Run misaligned giveaways
Accept irrelevant subscribers
Dilute positioning
Sacrifice engagement
The result?
Growth without depth.
And depth is where revenue lives.
🔁 The smarter growth mindset
Instead of asking:
“How do I grow faster?”
Ask:
“Are the right people joining?”
Instead of optimizing:
Traffic
Follower count
Vanity milestones
Optimize:
Open rates
Replies
Retention
Conversion
Quality compounds.
Size alone doesn’t.
🏁 Final Thought
A newsletter isn’t a billboard.
It’s a relationship.
And relationships don’t scale through volume.
They scale through trust.
Focus on building the right audience—not the biggest one.
Growth becomes slower…
but stronger.
How was today's edition?
If you’ve ever thought about starting your own newsletter (or switching to a better platform), I’ve partnered with the beehiiv team to set you up with:
✅ 20% off your first 3 months
✅ A free 30-day trial, no credit card needed
