In partnership with
Hey, Grow Newsie reader!
Today we're diving deep into the art and science of crafting irresistible subject lines that get your newsletters opened, read, and acted upon.
Why Subject Lines Matter More Than You Think
Here's a sobering stat: 47% of recipients open an email based on the subject line alone. Your subject line isn't just the first impression—it's often the ONLY impression your newsletter gets to make.
Think of your subject line as the headline of a newspaper sitting on a newsstand. In a sea of competing messages, it needs to grab attention, create curiosity, and compel action in just a few words.
The 15 Email Subject Line Tips That Actually Work
1. Keep It Short and Sweet
Subject lines with 70 characters max receive the most opens. Mobile users see even fewer characters, so front-load your most important words.
Example:
❌ "This week's newsletter contains amazing tips for growing your business and increasing revenue"
✅ "5 ways to double revenue this month"
2. Use Numbers and Lists
Numbers create structure and set clear expectations. They also stand out in crowded inboxes.
Examples:
"7 newsletter growth hacks that actually work"
"The #1 mistake killing your open rates"
"3-step formula for viral content"
Sponsored by: GURU
You’re invited to the world's largest email marketing conference.
Become an email marketing guru at the GURU conference. It’s two days full of all things email marketing. Learn more about newsletters. deliverability, design trends, AI, and what NOT to do with email.
What you can expect:
Keynote Speakers: Nicole Kidman, Amy Porterfield & more!
The latest digital trends in email marketing & how to increase performance.
Networking opportunities - each day!
Dj’s, dance contests (judged by Lance Bass, yes for real), breaking world records & MORE!
Spots are limited. It’s VIRTUAL. It’s FREE. It’s time to become an email marketing GURU. Join 25,000+ marketers on November 6th & 7th. Don’t miss out!
3. Create Urgency (Without Being Spammy)
Urgency works, but avoid overused phrases like "Act Now!" Instead, use subtle time-based language.
Examples:
"Last chance to join our workshop"
"Ending tonight: Premium access"
"48 hours left for early bird pricing"
4. Ask Compelling Questions
Questions engage the reader's curiosity and create an open loop their brain wants to close.
Examples:
"Are you making this newsletter mistake?"
"What if I told you email is NOT dead?"
"Ready to 10x your subscriber count?"
5. Use Power Words Strategically
Individual words like "Invitation," "news," and "new" have higher opens, while overused terms like "free" and "offer" can hurt performance.
High-performing words:
Secret, Exclusive, Behind-the-scenes
New, Fresh, Latest
Proven, Results, Success
Mistake, Warning, Alert
6. Personalize Beyond First Names
Personalize your subject lines by including the name of your subscribers in your subject lines, but go deeper with behavioral and preference-based personalization.
Examples:
"Hey [Name], your newsletter strategy needs this"
"For SaaS founders: This changed everything"
"Because you loved our last post about SEO..."
7. Tease Your Best Content
Give readers a preview of your most valuable content without giving everything away.
Examples:
"The tool that grew our list by 10,000 subscribers"
"Inside: My $50K launch strategy breakdown"
"The subject line that got 67% opens"
Reference others' success, popular content, or trending topics to build credibility.
Examples:
"How 500+ creators grow their newsletters"
"The strategy behind ConvertKit's success"
"Why everyone's talking about this growth hack"
9. Create Fear of Missing Out (FOMO)
Help readers understand what they'll miss if they don't open your email.
Examples:
"Don't miss this week's breakthrough tip"
"While you were sleeping, this happened"
"The opportunity most newsletters ignore"
10. Use Brackets and Parentheses
These create visual breaks and can house important information like categories or benefits.
Examples:
"Newsletter growth [Advanced Tactics]"
"Your open rates (and how to fix them)"
"[Case Study] From 0 to 10K subscribers"
11. Reference Current Events or Seasons
Tie into what's happening now to create relevance and timeliness.
Examples:
"New Year, New Newsletter Strategy"
"Black Friday lessons for newsletter growth"
"What the iOS update means for your emails"
12. Use Contradiction or Controversy
Challenge common beliefs or present unexpected viewpoints (while staying truthful).
Examples:
"Why I stopped using welcome sequences"
"The growth hack that actually hurts retention"
"Popular advice that's killing newsletters"
13. Promise Transformation
Show the before and after state your content will provide.
Examples:
"From 100 to 10,000 subscribers in 90 days"
"How I went from ignored to industry expert"
"Transform your opens with one simple change"
14. Use Incomplete Thoughts
Create curiosity by starting a thought but not finishing it.
Examples:
"The thing nobody tells you about..."
"What I wish I knew before..."
"The reason your newsletters..."
15. Test Everything
A/B test different approaches with small segments before sending to your full list. Test one element at a time: length, tone, personalization, or structure.
Advanced Subject Line Strategies
The Curiosity Gap Method
Create a gap between what readers know and what they want to know. Make the payoff worth the click.
Formula: Known information + intriguing unknown = compelling subject line
Example: "Your newsletter is missing this one thing (it's not what you think)"
The Benefit Stack
Layer multiple benefits into one subject line without making it cluttered.
Example: "Grow faster, stress less, earn more: The newsletter system that works"
The Story Starter
Begin a narrative that can only be completed by opening the email.
Example: "The email that changed my business forever started like this..."
Common Subject Line Mistakes to Avoid
ALL CAPS SCREAMING - Looks spammy and unprofessional
Excessive punctuation!!! - Triggers spam filters
Misleading promises - Hurts trust and increases unsubscribes
Generic templates - "Newsletter #47" tells readers nothing
Emoji overload 🎉🔥💰 - One or two max, if they fit your brand
Spelling mistakes - Always proofread before sending
Too clever for clarity - If it's confusing, it won't get opened
Your Subject Line Optimization Action Plan
Week 1: Audit Your Current Performance
Review your last 10 newsletter subject lines
Identify your highest and lowest performing ones
Note patterns in length, tone, and structure
Week 2: Create Your Testing Framework
Set up A/B testing for subject lines
Choose 3-5 techniques from this list to test
Document your baseline open rates
Week 3: Implement and Test
Test one technique per send
Track opens, clicks, and unsubscribes
Build your own data on what works for YOUR audience
Week 4: Analyze and Optimize
Review your results
Double down on winning formulas
Create templates for your best-performing patterns
Tools to Supercharge Your Subject Lines
CoSchedule Headline Analyzer - Scores your subject lines
SubjectLine.com - A/B testing and analytics
Mailchimp's Subject Line Researcher - See how similar lines perform
Omnisend Subject Line Tester - Free scoring tool
The Bottom Line
Great subject lines aren't about tricks or manipulation—they're about clearly communicating value and creating genuine curiosity about your content. The best subject lines match your audience's language, address their specific needs, and accurately represent what's inside your newsletter.
Remember: your subject line is a promise. Make sure your content delivers on that promise, or you'll lose trust faster than you can gain opens.
Keep growing!
With love,
Nikhil
How was today's edition?
If you’ve ever thought about starting your own newsletter (or switching to a better platform), I’ve partnered with the beehiiv team to set you up with:
✅ 20% off your first 3 months
✅ A free 30-day trial, no credit card needed
