In partnership with
Hey, Grow Newsie reader!
The festive season is here, and your inbox is about to get crowded. During the holidays, the average subscriber receives 111 emails per day—and that number only climbs higher in December.
So how do you cut through the noise and keep your subscribers engaged when everyone's competing for attention?
Today, I'm sharing 12 creative strategies to engage newsletter subscribers during holidays, backed by research and real examples from brands crushing it this season.
Sponsored by: GUIDDE
Effortless Tutorial Video Creation with Guidde
Transform your team’s static training materials into dynamic, engaging video guides with Guidde.
Here’s what you’ll love about Guidde:
1️⃣ Easy to Create: Turn PDFs or manuals into stunning video tutorials with a single click.
2️⃣ Easy to Update: Update video content in seconds to keep your training materials relevant.
3️⃣ Easy to Localize: Generate multilingual guides to ensure accessibility for global teams.
Empower your teammates with interactive learning.
And the best part? The browser extension is 100% free.
Why Holiday Engagement Matters
Before we dive in, here's a stat that'll blow your mind: emails sent by holiday and seasonal brands drive 35.9% open rates and capture 1.5% of clicks—significantly higher than other retail sectors.
The holiday season isn't just busy; it's your biggest opportunity to:
Build deeper subscriber relationships
Drive revenue without expensive ads
Reactivate dormant subscribers
Position your newsletter as a trusted resource
Let's make it count.
1. Create Holiday Gift Guides That Solve Problems
Gift guides reduce decision fatigue and can increase click-through rates by up to 30%.
How to do it:
Segment by recipient type: "Gifts for Her," "Under $50," "Last-Minute Ideas"
Include clear product images with direct links
Keep descriptions short (2-3 sentences max)
Add customer reviews for social proof
Pro tip: Don't wait until December. Smart brands publish gift guides in early November when shoppers are just starting to plan.
2. Launch a "12 Days of..." Campaign
Create sustained engagement through daily surprises. Each email reveals a new offer, product spotlight, or exclusive content.
Why it works:
Builds anticipation and FOMO
Encourages daily inbox checks
Provides multiple touchpoints without feeling spammy
Example structure:
Days 1-4: Product spotlights
Days 5-8: Flash discounts
Days 9-11: Behind-the-scenes content
Day 12: Grand finale offer
3. Use Interactive Content to Boost Engagement
Interactive elements can increase click-through rates by up to 50%.
Ideas to try:
Holiday trivia or quizzes ("Which holiday gift suits you best?")
Polls ("Gingerbread or snickerdoodles?")
Countdown timers for limited offers
Interactive advent calendars with daily reveals
Keep entry mechanics simple—one click should be all it takes to participate.
Non-promotional value builds trust and connection. Recipe emails offer a perfect way to showcase your brand personality while helping subscribers.
What to include:
Easy-to-follow instructions
High-quality images
Printable versions
Ways your products naturally fit in
This approach works beyond food brands—think holiday decoration tutorials, gift-wrapping tips, or seasonal self-care routines.
5. Highlight Your Giving Campaign
Charitable donations increase by 42% during November and December. Your subscribers want to be part of something meaningful.
How to execute:
Partner with a local or national cause
Let subscribers vote on which charity receives donations
Share the impact of their participation
Include donation receipts or updates
Remember: This demonstrates social responsibility and creates emotional connections that last beyond the holidays.
6. Create a Digital Countdown Experience
Transform the traditional countdown into an interactive engagement driver.
Implementation:
Send weekly emails with different themes
Include exclusive offers that unlock each week
Use visual calendar layouts
Add gamification elements (badges for engagement)
This keeps your newsletter top-of-mind throughout the entire season, not just on key shopping days.
7. Send Behind-the-Scenes Team Content
People buy from people they like. Show the humans behind your brand.
Content ideas:
Team holiday traditions
Office decoration photos
Personal product recommendations from staff
Holiday prep behind-the-scenes videos
Key insight: Personal product picks feel genuine, not sales-driven, and build trust through authentic connections.
8. Run a Strategic Holiday Giveaway
Giveaways are one of the fastest ways to boost newsletter engagement during the holidays.
Best practices:
Keep entry simple (reply, click, or vote)
Choose prizes people actually want
Announce winners quickly (before Christmas)
Use giveaways to cross-promote social channels
Offer small discounts to all participants
9. Offer Exclusive Subscriber-Only Perks
Make your email subscribers feel like VIPs.
Exclusive perks to consider:
Early access to holiday sales
Subscriber-only discount codes
Free shipping thresholds
First dibs on limited-edition products
Bonus content or resources
Pro tip: Announce these perks in your subject line: "🎁 Subscriber Exclusive: Early Holiday Access Inside"
10. Optimize Your Holiday Email Frequency
Frequency is crucial during holidays, but there's a balance.
The strategy:
Set clear expectations (e.g., "Check back every Sunday for 6 weeks")
Focus on quality over quantity
Segment based on engagement levels
Never send to addresses that haven't opened in 6+ months
Data point: The best-performing holiday emails have 4-word subject lines and provide value with every send.
11. Personalize With Dynamic Content
Dynamic content changes based on subscriber preferences, making each email feel custom-made.
What to personalize:
Product recommendations based on browsing history
Location-specific content or events
Names in subject lines and greetings
Content based on past purchases
Example: "Sarah, your holiday gifts are here" outperforms "Holiday sale inside!" by a significant margin.
12. Send a Post-Holiday Campaign
Don't stop when December ends. Post-holiday inboxes are quieter—use that to your advantage.
Post-holiday ideas:
Year-in-review content
Thank you messages with no sales pitch
New Year goal-setting resources
"Last chance" inventory clearance
Sneak peeks at what's coming in the new year
Why this works: People are relaxed, their inboxes are manageable, and they're more receptive to thoughtful content.
Technical Tips for Holiday Success
Keep Emails Mobile-Optimized
More people check email on mobile during holidays. Ensure:
Single-column layouts
Large, tappable buttons
Fast-loading images
Readable fonts (minimum 14pt)
Write Compelling Subject Lines
Use the subscriber's name
Include emojis strategically (🎅, 🎁, 🎄)
Create urgency ("Last Hours: Sale Ends Tonight!")
Keep it under 50 characters
Design for Festivity (But Don't Overdo It)
Use holiday colors tastefully
Add subtle animations or GIFs
Include seasonal imagery
Maintain brand consistency
Metrics to Track
Monitor these KPIs throughout your holiday campaigns:
Open rates: Holiday emails should exceed your baseline by 10-15%
Click-through rates: Target 1.5% or higher
Conversion rates: Compare holiday vs. regular campaigns
Unsubscribe rates: Should stay under 0.5%
Revenue per email: Your ultimate success metric
Use A/B testing to continuously optimize subject lines, send times, and content formats.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
❌ Bombarding subscribers with daily promotional emails
❌ Ignoring segmentation and sending the same message to everyone
❌ Starting too late (begin planning in September/October)
❌ Being too salesy without providing genuine value
❌ Neglecting to clean your list before the holiday rush
❌ Forgetting to thank subscribers after the season ends
Your Holiday Engagement Action Plan
Here's your roadmap for the next 30 days:
Week 1:
Audit your subscriber list and segment by engagement
Plan your holiday content calendar
Design festive email templates
Week 2:
Launch your first holiday campaign (gift guide or early access)
Set up automated countdown emails
Create interactive content pieces
Week 3:
Send weekly value-driven content (recipes, DIY, tips)
Launch giveaway or contest
Share behind-the-scenes content
Week 4:
Execute main holiday promotions
Send last-minute gift ideas
Remind about shipping deadlines
Post-Holiday:
Send thank-you emails
Clear inventory with New Year sales
Gather feedback and analyze results
Final Thoughts
Learning how to engage newsletter subscribers during holidays isn't about sending more emails—it's about sending the right emails that provide value, spark joy, and build lasting relationships.
The brands that win during the holidays are those that balance promotion with genuine helpfulness, that treat their subscribers like friends rather than transactions, and that show up consistently with quality content.
This holiday season, be the newsletter your subscribers actually look forward to opening.
Keep growing!
With love,
Nikhil
How was today's edition?
If you’ve ever thought about starting your own newsletter (or switching to a better platform), I’ve partnered with the beehiiv team to set you up with:
✅ 20% off your first 3 months
✅ A free 30-day trial, no credit card needed
