In partnership with
Hey, Grow Newsie reader!
Let's talk about the metric that keeps newsletter creators up at night: unsubscribe rates.
If you're watching subscribers drop off faster than you can gain them, you're not alone. But here's the good news: with the right strategies, you can cut your unsubscribe rate in half—and I'm going to show you exactly how.
First, let's establish a baseline. The average newsletter unsubscribe rate hovers between 0.1% and 0.5%. If you're above 0.5%, it's time to take action. Anything under 0.2% is considered excellent.
But here's what matters more than hitting these benchmarks: understanding why people unsubscribe and fixing those issues systematically.
Sponsored by: GUIDDE
Effortless Tutorial Video Creation with Guidde
Transform your team’s static training materials into dynamic, engaging video guides with Guidde.
Here’s what you’ll love about Guidde:
1️⃣ Easy to Create: Turn PDFs or manuals into stunning video tutorials with a single click.
2️⃣ Easy to Update: Update video content in seconds to keep your training materials relevant.
3️⃣ Easy to Localize: Generate multilingual guides to ensure accessibility for global teams.
Empower your teammates with interactive learning.
And the best part? The browser extension is 100% free.
The Top 3 Reasons Subscribers Leave
Research shows that subscribers unsubscribe for three primary reasons:
Too many emails (69% of unsubscribers)
Irrelevant content (53.8%)
They signed up for something else (one-time incentive seekers)
Now, let's address each with proven solutions.
Strategy #1: Implement List Segmentation (The 50% Solution)
Here's a stat that should get your attention: highly segmented email campaigns can reduce unsubscribe rates by 50% compared to unsegmented lists.
Action steps:
Segment by at least 2 conditions (behavior + demographics)
Create preference centers where subscribers choose their interests
Track engagement patterns and adjust segments quarterly
Send different content to highly engaged vs. dormant subscribers
Example: Instead of sending all subscribers your weekly roundup, create segments for "product updates," "industry news," and "growth tips"—then let readers choose.
Strategy #2: Perfect Your Email Frequency
The sweet spot? Most newsletters perform best at 1-2 emails per week. But here's the key: consistency beats frequency.
Action steps:
Set clear expectations at signup about frequency
Offer frequency options (daily digest vs. weekly roundup)
Monitor unsubscribe patterns after specific campaigns
Never surprise subscribers with sudden frequency changes
Pro tip: If you're launching a new campaign series, announce it first and let people opt in separately.
Strategy #3: Use Double Opt-In
This might seem counterintuitive (fewer signups initially), but double opt-in creates a list of people who actually want to hear from you. The result? Lower unsubscribe rates long-term.
Action steps:
Add a confirmation step after signup
Make the confirmation email compelling (tease exclusive content)
Use this as an opportunity to set expectations
Consider it a quality filter, not a barrier
Strategy #4: Mobile Optimization Is Non-Negotiable
Over 50% of emails are opened on mobile devices. If your newsletter isn't optimized, you're asking people to unsubscribe.
Action steps:
Use responsive design templates
Keep font sizes readable (14-18px for body text)
Test on multiple devices before sending
Use single-column layouts for mobile
Compress images for faster loading
Strategy #5: Create an Exit Strategy
When someone clicks unsubscribe, you have one last chance to save them.
Action steps:
Offer to reduce email frequency instead of full unsubscribe
Provide granular content preferences
Ask for specific feedback (1-2 questions max)
Consider a "pause" option (30-90 days)
Example: Grammarly's unsubscribe page offers multiple mailing lists to choose from rather than forcing an all-or-nothing decision.
Strategy #6: Regular List Cleaning
Paradoxically, sometimes you should unsubscribe people yourself. Dead weight on your list hurts deliverability and skews your metrics.
Action steps:
Identify subscribers who haven't opened in 90+ days
Send a re-engagement campaign first
Remove truly inactive subscribers
Focus on quality over quantity
The Metrics That Matter
Beyond unsubscribe rate, track these:
Open rate (industry average: 21-25%)
Click-through rate (industry average: 2-3%)
Engagement score (opens + clicks + time spent)
Spam complaint rate (should be under 0.1%)
Quick Wins You Can Implement Today
Add a preference center - 30 minutes setup time
Audit your subject lines - Avoid spam triggers and overpromising
Personalize beyond first names - Use past behavior, location, or interests
A/B test sending times - Find when YOUR audience is most receptive
Review your unsubscribe copy - Make it respectful, learn from it
Reducing your unsubscribe rate isn't about tricking people into staying. It's about building a list of genuinely engaged subscribers who value what you send.
Focus on:
Sending the right content
To the right people
At the right frequency
With clear value proposition
Do this consistently, and you'll not only reduce unsubscribes—you'll build a newsletter community that actively looks forward to your emails.
Your Action Plan for This Week
Calculate your current unsubscribe rate
Implement one segmentation strategy
Add a preference center to your unsubscribe page
Survey 10 subscribers about what they want more/less of
Remember: A smaller, engaged list beats a large, uninterested one every single time.
Keep growing!
With love,
Nikhil
How was today's edition?
If you’ve ever thought about starting your own newsletter (or switching to a better platform), I’ve partnered with the beehiiv team to set you up with:
✅ 20% off your first 3 months
✅ A free 30-day trial, no credit card needed
