In partnership with

At some point, every newsletter creator faces this question:

Should I monetize with sponsorships

or build a paid subscription?

Both work.

Both fail.

Both look better from the outside.

Let’s talk about the real trade-offs.

Sponsored by: WISPR FLOW

Better prompts. Better AI output.

AI gets smarter when your input is complete. Wispr Flow helps you think out loud and capture full context by voice, then turns that speech into a clean, structured prompt you can paste into ChatGPT, Claude, or any assistant. No more chopping up thoughts into typed paragraphs. Preserve constraints, examples, edge cases, and tone by speaking them once. The result is faster iteration, more precise outputs, and less time re-prompting. Try Wispr Flow for AI or see a 30-second demo.

💰 Sponsorships: The leverage model

Sponsorships work best when:

  • You have consistent engagement

  • Your audience fits a clear buyer persona

  • You want revenue without gating content

Pros:

  • Readers stay free

  • Growth remains frictionless

  • Revenue can scale with audience size

Cons:

  • Income depends on volume

  • You need ongoing sales effort

  • Revenue fluctuates

Sponsorships reward reach + positioning.

🔒 Subscriptions: The depth model

Subscriptions work best when:

  • You solve a specific problem

  • Your content creates clear outcomes

  • Your audience deeply trusts you

Pros:

  • Predictable recurring revenue

  • Smaller audience can still earn well

  • Stronger community loyalty

Cons:

  • Slower audience growth

  • Higher expectations

  • Retention pressure

Subscriptions reward clarity + consistency.

📉 The hidden trade-off most creators ignore

Sponsorships require:

👉 Audience scale.

Subscriptions require:

👉 Audience intensity.

One optimizes for breadth.

The other optimizes for depth.

You can’t optimize both at the same time without friction.

🧠 The smarter sequence

Instead of choosing permanently, ask:

  • Am I still building reach?

  • Or am I ready to monetize trust?

Many creators succeed by:

  1. Growing free with light sponsorships

  2. Introducing premium depth later

  3. Blending both strategically

Hybrid models often outperform pure ones.

🧮 A simple rule of thumb

If your newsletter helps readers:

  • Make money

  • Save money

  • Gain leverage

Subscriptions can work early.

If your newsletter builds:

  • Awareness

  • Inspiration

  • Broad education

Sponsorships usually scale better first.

🏁 Final Thought

Sponsorships monetize attention.

Subscriptions monetize transformation.

The best choice isn’t about trend.

It’s about where your newsletter sits today.

Revenue follows clarity.

How was today's edition?

Your vote will help us make Grow Newsie better!

Login or Subscribe to participate

If you’ve ever thought about starting your own newsletter (or switching to a better platform), I’ve partnered with the beehiiv team to set you up with:

20% off your first 3 months
A free 30-day trial, no credit card needed

Keep Reading