In partnership with
Hey, Grow Newsie reader!
What if I told you that you could potentially double your newsletter revenue without adding a single new subscriber to your list?
Sounds too good to be true? Today, we're diving deep into the goldmine that's probably sitting right under your nose: subscriber segmentation through strategic tagging.
Here's a sobering stat: According to Mailchimp, segmented campaigns receive 14.31% higher open rates and generate 100.95% more clicks than non-segmented campaigns.
Yet 90% of newsletter creators are still sending the same generic email to their entire list.
That's like a restaurant serving the same meal to someone celebrating an anniversary and someone grabbing a quick lunch. Both are hungry, but their needs couldn't be more different.
Sponsored by: Roku
Kickstart your holiday campaigns
CTV should be central to any growth marketer’s Q4 strategy. And with Roku Ads Manager, launching high-performing holiday campaigns is simple and effective.
With our intuitive interface, you can set up A/B tests to dial in the most effective messages and offers, then drive direct on-screen purchases via the remote with shoppable Action Ads that integrate with your Shopify store for a seamless checkout experience.
Don’t wait to get started. Streaming on Roku picks up sharply in early October. By launching your campaign now, you can capture early shopping demand and be top of mind as the seasonal spirit kicks in.
Get a $500 ad credit when you spend your first $500 today with code: ROKUADS500. Terms apply.
Why Tagging Is Your Secret Revenue Weapon
Think of tags as invisible labels that tell you exactly who your subscribers are and what they want. But here's where most people get it wrong – they think tags are just for organization.
Tags are actually revenue multipliers.
When you know that Sarah is a "beginner blogger interested in monetization" and John is an "experienced creator looking for advanced growth tactics," you can send them completely different content that speaks directly to their needs.
Result? Higher engagement, stronger relationships, and significantly more sales.
The 5-Tag System That Generated $127K in Additional Revenue
Last year, I worked with a newsletter creator who implemented this exact system. Her list size stayed the same (8,500 subscribers), but her revenue jumped from $43K to $170K annually.
Here's the exact tagging framework she used:
beginnerintermediateadvanced
How to implement: Add this question to your welcome sequence: "What best describes your current experience with [your niche]?"
growth-focusedmonetization-focusedcontent-focused
How to implement: Track which lead magnets people download or which newsletter topics get the most engagement from each subscriber.
highly-engaged(opens 80%+ of emails)moderately-engaged(opens 30-79%)low-engagement(opens <30%)
How to implement: Most email platforms can auto-tag based on engagement metrics.
hot-prospect(clicked pricing pages, attended sales webinars)warm-prospect(engaged with product-related content)cold-prospect(little to no commercial engagement)
How to implement: Set up automatic tags when people visit key pages or take specific actions.
subscriber(free content only)customer(made at least one purchase)vip-customer(multiple purchases or high-value purchase)
How to implement: Integrate your email platform with your payment processor for automatic tagging.
The Revenue-Boosting Campaigns You Can Send Today
Once you have these tags in place, here are the campaign types that will immediately impact your bottom line:
Campaign #1: The Beginner's Fast Track
Send to: beginner + growth-focused tags Subject: "Skip the learning curve: Your 30-day growth blueprint" Content:Step-by-step guide with links to your beginner-friendly paid products
Expected lift: 35-50% higher conversion rates vs. generic campaigns
Campaign #2: The Advanced Insider Series
Send to: advanced + highly-engaged tags Subject: "Advanced strategy (not for beginners)" Content: Premium insights and exclusive offers for higher-ticket products
Expected lift: 60-80% higher click-through rates
Campaign #3: The Win-Back Sequence
Send to: low-engagement + customer tags Subject: "Did we lose you? Here's what's new..." Content: Re-engagement campaign with exclusive customer perks
Expected lift: 25-40% improvement in reactivation rates
Campaign #4: The VIP Treatment
Send to: vip-customer + hot-prospect tags Subject: "VIP early access: New product launching Monday" Content:Exclusive preview with special pricing for best customers
Expected lift: 200-300% higher conversion rates vs. general announcements
Quick Implementation Checklist
Week 1: Set Up Your Foundation
Choose 3-5 core tags that align with your business model
Create automated tagging rules in your email platform
Add tagging questions to your welcome sequence
Week 2: Tag Your Existing Subscribers
Use engagement data to retroactively tag current subscribers
Send a "get to know you better" survey to gather additional tag data
Set up tracking for future automatic tagging
Week 3: Launch Your First Segmented Campaign
Choose your highest-value segment
Create targeted content for this specific group
Send and measure results vs. your typical campaigns
Week 4: Scale and Optimize
Analyze performance data from your first segmented campaign
Create additional targeted campaigns for other segments
Set up ongoing automated sequences for each tag combination
The Tools That Make This Effortless
For Beginners: ConvertKit or Mailchimp both offer solid tagging features and are beginner-friendly.
For Intermediate Users: ActiveCampaign provides the most sophisticated tagging and automation capabilities.
For Advanced Users: Consider custom solutions or advanced integrations with tools like Zapier to create complex tagging workflows.
Avoiding the 3 Fatal Tagging Mistakes
Mistake #1: Over-tagging Don't create 47 different tags. Start with 5-8 core tags that directly relate to your monetization strategy.
Mistake #2: Set-it-and-forget-it mentality Tags need maintenance. Review and clean up your tags quarterly to ensure they remain relevant.
Mistake #3: Tagging without action Having tags means nothing if you don't create targeted campaigns. Plan your segmented content calendar alongside your tagging strategy.
Your Next Action Step
Here's what I want you to do right now:
Open your email platform
Create three tags:
beginner,intermediate, andadvancedAdd one question to your welcome sequence asking about experience level
Plan one targeted campaign for your largest segment
This single action could increase your next campaign's performance by 30%+ within two weeks.
The Segmentation Snowball Effect: Every piece of content you create should serve double duty. While providing value to your audience, it should also help you better understand and tag your subscribers.
Add one simple call-to-action to each newsletter: "Reply and let me know: Are you struggling more with [Option A] or [Option B]?" Then tag respondents accordingly.
Keep growing!
With love,
Nikhil
How was today's edition?
If you’ve ever thought about starting your own newsletter (or switching to a better platform), I’ve partnered with the beehiiv team to set you up with:
✅ 20% off your first 3 months
✅ A free 30-day trial, no credit card needed
