In partnership with
One of the most common questions creators ask is:
“Should I start with a free newsletter or a paid one?”
The wrong answer?
“It depends.”
The right answer?
It depends on where you are—not where you want to be.
Let’s break it down clearly.
Sponsored by: LEVANTA
The Future of Shopping? AI + Actual Humans.
AI has changed how consumers shop by speeding up research. But one thing hasn’t changed: shoppers still trust people more than AI.
Levanta’s new Affiliate 3.0 Consumer Report reveals a major shift in how shoppers blend AI tools with human influence. Consumers use AI to explore options, but when it comes time to buy, they still turn to creators, communities, and real experiences to validate their decisions.
The data shows:
Only 10% of shoppers buy through AI-recommended links
87% discover products through creators, blogs, or communities they trust
Human sources like reviews and creators rank higher in trust than AI recommendations
The most effective brands are combining AI discovery with authentic human influence to drive measurable conversions.
Affiliate marketing isn’t being replaced by AI, it’s being amplified by it.
Free newsletters excel at:
Building trust
Learning what your audience cares about
Refining your voice and positioning
Growing through sharing and referrals
If you’re still figuring out:
Your niche
Your value proposition
What people will actually pay for
Free is not a weakness—it’s a research phase.
Paid newsletters work when:
The outcome is specific
The pain is urgent
The audience already trusts you
People don’t pay for “more content.”
They pay for:
Shortcuts
Clarity
Confidence
Results
If you already solve a clear problem, charging early can save you time.
❌ The biggest mistake creators make
They rush to paid without proof of value.
Low conversions don’t mean:
“Paid newsletters don’t work”
They usually mean:
The promise isn’t clear
The audience isn’t ready
The problem isn’t sharp enough
Monetization before trust feels forced.
Trust before monetization feels natural.
🧠 The smarter path most creators miss
Start free, but design for paid.
That means:
Write with outcomes in mind
Notice what readers reply to
Track which editions get shared
Test small paid ideas early
Your free newsletter should quietly prepare your paid offer.
📈 When to switch (or add paid)
You’re ready when:
Readers ask for deeper help
You repeat the same advice often
You can describe your paid value in one sentence
Paid isn’t a milestone.
It’s a response to demand.
🏁 Final Thought
Free builds trust.
Paid builds leverage.
The best newsletters don’t choose one forever—they sequence them correctly.
Start where learning is fastest.
Monetize when clarity is strongest.
How was today's edition?
If you’ve ever thought about starting your own newsletter (or switching to a better platform), I’ve partnered with the beehiiv team to set you up with:
✅ 20% off your first 3 months
✅ A free 30-day trial, no credit card needed
