In partnership with
Hey, Grow Newsie reader!
You've worked hard to get someone to subscribe to your newsletter. Now comes the critical part: keeping them engaged.
Here's a sobering stat: 74% of new subscribers expect a welcome email immediately after signing up. But here's the good news—welcome emails get 4x higher open rates and 5x higher click rates than regular emails.
Today, I'm sharing the exact welcome email sequence template that top newsletters use to transform casual subscribers into loyal fans who eagerly await every edition.
Why You Need a Welcome Email Sequence (Not Just One Email)
A single welcome email is good. A strategic sequence is transformational.
A welcome sequence gives you multiple touchpoints to:
Build trust gradually without overwhelming new subscribers
Segment your audience based on engagement
Deliver value consistently in those crucial first days
Set clear expectations for what's coming
Convert free subscribers to paid (if you're monetizing)
The sweet spot? 5 emails over 7-10 days.
Sponsored by: KOJO
Find your next winning ad creative in seconds with AI
Most AI tools promise you thousands of ads at the click of a button. But do you really need more ads—or just better ones?
Kojo helps you cut through the noise. We analyze your paid social data to uncover the ideas with the highest chance of success. Then, our AI predicts which concepts will perform best, so you don’t waste budget testing what won’t work.
Instead of drowning in endless variations, Kojo sends your best idea straight to a real human creator who makes it engaging, authentic, and ready to win on social. The entire process takes less than 20 seconds, giving you certainty before you spend and better performance without the waste.
Why gamble on guesswork or settle for AI spam when you can launch ads proven to work, made by people, and backed by data?
The 5-Email Welcome Sequence Template That Converts
Email 1: The Instant Welcome (Sent immediately)
Subject Line: "Welcome to [Newsletter Name]! Here's what happens next..."
Goals: Confirm subscription, set expectations, deliver immediate value
What to Include:
Warm, personal greeting that reinforces their decision to subscribe
Brief explanation of what your newsletter is about
Clear outline of what they'll receive and how often
One quick win—a helpful resource, template, or insight they can use today
Call-to-action: Reply to this email with their biggest challenge
Pro Tip: Keep it under 150 words. They're excited but busy. Respect their time.
Example Opening: "Hey [Name], welcome aboard! I'm thrilled you're here. Every Thursday, you'll get one actionable strategy to grow your newsletter—no fluff, just tactics I've personally tested. To kick things off, here's the exact subject line template that increased my open rates by 34%..."
Email 2: The Origin Story (Day 2)
Subject Line: "Why I started [Newsletter Name] (and why you'll love it)"
Goals: Build connection, establish credibility, humanize your brand
What to Include:
Your personal story—why you started this newsletter
The problem you're solving for readers
Your unique perspective or approach
A vulnerable moment or lesson learned
Social proof (subscriber count, testimonial, or achievement)
Pro Tip: Vulnerability creates connection. Share a genuine struggle or pivotal moment.
Example Structure: "Two years ago, I was exactly where you might be today—struggling to grow my newsletter past 200 subscribers. I tried everything: growth hacks, expensive tools, complicated funnels. Nothing worked until I discovered [your unique insight]. That's when everything changed..."
Email 3: The Value Bomb (Day 4)
Subject Line: "The [specific tactic] that changed everything for me"
Goals: Deliver massive value, demonstrate expertise, encourage engagement
What to Include:
Your best tip, framework, or strategy
Step-by-step explanation with examples
Why it works (the psychology or data behind it)
How they can implement it today
Invitation to reply with their results or questions
Pro Tip: Give away your best stuff early. It builds trust and demonstrates you're not holding back.
Example Content: "Today, I'm sharing the exact welcome sequence template that helped me convert 42% of new subscribers into engaged readers (vs. the industry average of 18%). Here's the 5-email framework..."
Email 4: The Community Invite (Day 6)
Subject Line: "Join 5,000+ newsletter creators (and get exclusive perks)"
Goals: Foster community, increase engagement, introduce other touchpoints
What to Include:
Invitation to your other platforms (Discord, LinkedIn, Twitter/X)
Exclusive benefits of being part of the community
Showcase community wins or member spotlights
Behind-the-scenes content or exclusive resource
Clear calls-to-action to connect
Pro Tip: Create FOMO by highlighting what active community members are achieving.
Example: "You're not just a subscriber—you're part of a community of 5,000+ newsletter creators who are crushing it. Last week, member Sarah grew from 300 to 1,200 subscribers using our Discord community's feedback. Want in? Here's your exclusive access..."
Email 5: The Ask (Day 9-10)
Subject Line: "Quick question about [Newsletter Name]..."
Goals: Gather feedback, segment audience, introduce paid offerings (if applicable)
What to Include:
Genuine ask for feedback (what they want more of)
Simple survey or reply-based questions
Segmentation question (experience level, goals, challenges)
Soft introduction to paid products or premium tier (if applicable)
Reminder of what's coming next in regular newsletters
Pro Tip: Make them feel heard. Actually read and respond to replies.
Example: "You've been with me for over a week now, and I'd love your input: What's your #1 newsletter growth challenge right now? Hit reply and let me know—I read every response and often build entire editions around your questions. P.S. If you're interested in 1-on-1 coaching, I've opened 3 spots this month..."
Technical Setup Tips
Timing Matters:
Email 1: Immediate (within seconds of signup)
Email 2: 36-48 hours later
Email 3: 2 days after Email 2
Email 4: 2 days after Email 3
Email 5: 3 days after Email 4
Deliverability Best Practices:
Send from a personal email address (not noreply@)
Keep emails under 500 words (except Email 3)
Include plain text versions
Avoid spam trigger words
Always include an unsubscribe link
Automation Tools: Most email platforms make this easy: ConvertKit, Beehiiv, Substack, MailerLite, and ActiveCampaign all support automated sequences.
Measuring Success: Key Metrics to Track
Your welcome sequence should outperform your regular emails. Track these metrics:
Open Rate: Aim for 50%+ (industry standard is 40-50% for welcome emails)
Click Rate: Shoot for 15%+ (vs. 2-3% for regular emails)
Reply Rate: 5-10% is excellent and indicates high engagement
Unsubscribe Rate: Should be under 1% for the entire sequence
Conversion Rate: If you're selling something, 2-5% is solid
Red Flags:
Open rates dropping significantly after Email 1? Your subject lines need work
Low click rates? Add more actionable, clickable content
High unsubscribes after Email 2-3? You're overselling or underwhelming
Bonus: 3 Welcome Sequence Mistakes to Avoid
1. The Info Dump Don't try to explain everything about yourself and your newsletter in Email 1. Spread information across the sequence. Each email should have ONE clear purpose.
2. The Hard Sell Resist the urge to pitch your paid products aggressively. Build trust first, sell later. Email 5 is soon enough.
3. The Ghost Don't create a welcome sequence and then disappear. Make sure your regular newsletter cadence is clear and consistent after the sequence ends.
Your Action Plan for This Week
Audit your current welcome email (or create one if you don't have it)
Map out your 5-email sequence using the template above
Write Email 1 and 2 and set them up in your email platform
Draft Emails 3-5 throughout the week
Turn on the automation and test it yourself
Remember: Your welcome sequence is working 24/7 for you, turning strangers into fans while you sleep. Invest time upfront to create something great, and it'll pay dividends for months and years to come.
Keep growing!
With love,
Nikhil
How was today's edition?
If you’ve ever thought about starting your own newsletter (or switching to a better platform), I’ve partnered with the beehiiv team to set you up with:
✅ 20% off your first 3 months
✅ A free 30-day trial, no credit card needed
